On April 27, 1667, one of the most striking transactions in literary history quietly took place: the English poet John Milton, blind and financially strained, sold the copyright of his epic poem Paradise Lost for just £10. At the time, the decision may have seemed practical—perhaps even necessary—but in retrospect, it stands as a powerful reminder of how uncertain the value of great art can be in its own moment.
Milton had spent years composing Paradise Lost, dictating the poem after losing his sight completely in 1652. The work itself is vast in scope and ambition, retelling the biblical story of the Fall of Man with a depth of philosophical, political, and theological reflection that few works have ever matched. Written in blank verse and spanning twelve books, it explores themes of free will, obedience, rebellion, and redemption. Today, it is widely regarded as one of the greatest works in the English language.
But in 1667, Milton’s circumstances were far from ideal. The political landscape of England had shifted dramatically following the Restoration of the monarchy in 1660. Milton, a staunch supporter of the Commonwealth and a defender of republican ideals, found himself on the losing side of history. Though he avoided severe punishment, his political associations damaged his standing and limited his opportunities. Combined with his blindness, this left him dependent on others and in need of income.
The publishing agreement he entered into with Samuel Simmons, a London printer, reflects both the norms of the time and Milton’s precarious situation. For an initial payment of £10, Milton transferred the rights to Paradise Lost. The contract did include provisions for additional payments—another £10 for each of the first three editions, contingent on their sales reaching certain thresholds. Even so, the total potential earnings were modest, especially when compared to the enduring value the poem would later achieve.
At the time of its publication, Paradise Lost did not immediately become the monumental success it is today. Its dense style, intellectual rigor, and unconventional portrayal of figures like Satan made it a challenging read for many. Yet over time, the poem gained recognition and admiration, influencing generations of writers, thinkers, and artists. Figures such as William Blake, John Keats, and Mary Shelley would draw inspiration from its themes and imagery, helping to cement its place in the literary canon.
The story of Milton’s £10 sale has since become symbolic. It highlights the often fragile relationship between artistic creation and financial reward, as well as the difficulty of recognizing true greatness in the present. Many works now considered masterpieces were initially overlooked or undervalued, and Milton’s experience is among the most famous examples.
Ultimately, April 27, 1667, is not just a date marking a simple business transaction. It represents a moment where necessity met genius, and where one of literature’s greatest achievements passed into the world under humble circumstances. Milton may not have reaped the full financial rewards of his labor, but his work has endured for centuries—far outlasting any sum of money that could have been exchanged for it.
Use this figure in the classroom
Discussion Questions
- Why might John Milton have accepted such a small payment for Paradise Lost, and what does this reveal about his circumstances?
- How does society determine the value of art, and can true value be recognized in its own time?
- In what ways did Milton’s blindness and political situation influence both his work and his legacy?
Classroom Activity
Have students step into the roles of 17th-century publisher and author. In pairs, one student plays Milton and the other a printer negotiating terms. Afterward, compare agreements and discuss how value, risk, and reputation shaped each negotiation.
Debate Prompt
“Great art is often undervalued in its own time.”
Students should argue for or against this statement using historical and modern examples.
Writing Assignment Idea
Ask students to write a short essay imagining they are John Milton on the day he sold the copyright. What thoughts, concerns, or hopes might he have had about his work and its future?
Printable Quote
“Long is the way and hard, that out of Hell leads up to light.”